✨ Welcome to Cryptid Coffee — Sign in to manage your subscription ✨

Mothman’s Midnight Brew 🦋

Bittersweet cocoa, born for night watch. ☕
Price:
$22.95 or subscribe and save up to 12.5%
12 oz Bag
Eyewitness Encounters 4.7/5 See Reviews
Pure & Tested - Mold Free • Mycotoxin Free • Heavy Metal Free
🏅 SCA Certified • 83.0 / 100
Evaluated by licensed Q-Certified graders, this Cryptid Coffee roast meets the elite standards of Specialty Grade Coffee. The above rating is an average of the blended beans that make up this roast.

*Subscriptions receive a recurring percent-off and do not qualify for the Coffee Savings Bundle discount. We always apply the best available single offer.

**All Cryptid Coffee orders including recurring subscriptions ship free!

The Point Pleasant Register ran a front page story on November 16, 1966 with the headline “Couples See Man-Sized Bird… Creature… In Area.” Sheriff George Johnson and Deputy Millard Halstead took statements and checked the site. Volunteer firefighters suggested a large heron, but primary witnesses maintained that what they saw did not match a known bird.
Origin
Brazil
Growth Altitude
~1,700 MASL
Roast Level
Dark
Flavor Notes:
🍫 Dark Chocolate ✨ Full Body ✨ Toasty
🦇 Whispers Beyond the Bridge

In the chill before dawn, when fog clings to the treetops of Point Pleasant, this dark roast awakens like the rustle of unseen wings. Bittersweet chocolate and toasted grain swirl through the cup, full-bodied and steady, carrying the calm tension between night and morning. Each sip feels deliberate — strong enough to face the unknown, smooth enough to savor the silence that follows. The roast is grounded, balanced, and confident, a beacon in the black.

🔥 Forged in the Shadows

Crafted from select South American beans known for their smooth texture and depth, this blend celebrates precision and darkness. Roasted deep to draw out its cocoa-rich soul, it reveals tones of nut, earth, and charred sweetness that settle into a velvet finish. The result is a cup that feels both grounded and unearthly — as if the forest itself exhaled a secret through the steam.

🌒 The Night Watcher’s Gift

As you drink, warmth gathers like lantern light in the dark. A pulse of chocolate softens the edges, while roasted grain hums beneath, steady as a heartbeat in the woods. It’s a flavor that lingers — quiet, rich, and a little haunting — perfect for nights spent chasing inspiration or watching the sky for what others refuse to see.

👁️ The Legend of the Winged One

In 1966, the Mothman appeared — a towering figure with glowing red eyes, haunting the skies above the Silver Bridge and the quiet streets of Point Pleasant. Some called it a warning, others a guardian. Either way, the legend endures: when the lights flicker and the wind shifts, you can almost feel the brush of wings against the dark. This roast carries that same energy — enigmatic, enduring, and unforgettable.

☕ Flavor at a Glance
  • 🍫 Flavor Notes: Bittersweet chocolate, roasted grain, earthy cocoa
  • 💪 Body: Full and smooth
  • 🍯 Sweetness: Subtle, balanced, and warming
  • 🍂 Acidity: Low and mellow
  • 🌌 Best Enjoyed: French press or pour-over, black or lightly creamed
💫 Cryptid Spotlight 💫 Mothman

Reports from Point Pleasant describe a tall, winged figure with burning red eyes seen around the TNT area in 1966 and 1967. Many witnesses felt a sudden, electric fear, others a strange calm, as if warned. The legend endures because the pattern endures: lights in the sky, footsteps on the steel, and a silence that feels intentional.

Hear the Call 🐾 Decaf calm, Devil-level depth. ☕

Pine Barrens Finest 🌲

ORIGIN
Indonesia/Sumatra
GROWTH ALTITUDE (MASL)
~1,600 MASL
ROAST LEVEL
Medium
🍫 Dark Chocolate ✨ Full Body ✨ Smooth
🐾 Track The Legend
Eyewitness Encounters: Mothman’s Midnight Brew 🦋 4.7/5 (48 Reviews)
Nina V. Verified Buyer
Eyewitness Encounters:
November 28, 2025

Really enjoyed this one. It brews strong but stays balanced, and the roasted cocoa flavor is clean and comforting. No bitterness, just a solid dark roast with a calm, steady feel. I’d definitely order it again.

Caleb J. Verified Buyer
Eyewitness Encounters:
November 25, 2025

Smooth, rich, and easy to drink. The chocolate notes come through clearly, and the finish is warm without being heavy. It’s a great dark roast for early mornings or late nights when you want something steady and reliable.

Alan H. Verified Buyer
Eyewitness Encounters:
November 24, 2025

This is the best dark roast I have every had. Rich and smooth. Also got the Sasquatch Supreme. Both coffees are great!

Jordan F. Verified Buyer
Eyewitness Encounters:
November 20, 2025

This roast surprised me in the best way. It feels balanced and comforting, and it makes the morning routine a lot more enjoyable. Definitely something I look forward to.

Kelly A. Verified Buyer
Eyewitness Encounters:
November 15, 2025

Seriously good coffee. Dark, smooth, and satisfying from the first sip to the last. It has become my regular coffee.

Evan S. Verified Buyer
Eyewitness Encounters:
November 13, 2025

This is the kind of coffee that makes you stop for a second after the first sip. Smooth, bold, and surprisingly calming.

Rachel K. Verified Buyer
Eyewitness Encounters:
November 7, 2025

I tried this and it quickly became my favorite dark roast. It is smooth, steady, and full of that rich chocolate flavor without any bitterness. I usually drink my coffee black and this one is perfect for that.

Jerry K Verified Buyer
Eyewitness Encounters:
November 3, 2025

Great robust flavor. Will buy again. Thanks!

Jerry R. Verified Buyer
Eyewitness Encounters:
October 29, 2025

The only dark roast I drink now. And not just because I am obsessed with Mothman. Keep that subscription coming!!

Ivy Rose Verified Buyer
Eyewitness Encounters:
October 22, 2025

Mothman would approve. Powerful, chocolate-forward, and super smooth.

Showing 10 of 48
Couldn’t load more. Try again.